Ballot Sharing Thread

To celebrate Ring of Honor’s upcoming 15th anniversary in February of 2017, Place to Be Nation and Voices of Wrestling are teaming up to present The Honor Roll: ROH’s 50 Greatest Wrestlers Ever, held exclusively on the Voices of Wrestling forums.
User avatar
supersonic
Posts: 3326
Joined: Fri Jul 03, 2015 5:12 am
Location: Edgar Martinez Dr S
Contact:

Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by supersonic » Mon Feb 27, 2017 11:41 am

Some real surprises on mine once I actually sat down and thought about it.

1. Bryan Danielson
2. Samoa Joe
3. AJ Styles
4. CM Punk
5. Austin Aries
6. Nigel McGuinness
7. Christopher Daniels
8. Jay Briscoe
9. Roderick Strong
10. Homicide
11. Kevin Steen
12. El Generico
13. Low Ki
14. KENTA
15. Mark Briscoe
16. Jimmy Jacobs
17. Jay Lethal
18. Alex Shelley
19. Chris Hero
20. Jimmy Rave
21. Claudio Castagnoli
22. Paul London
23. Davey Richards
24. Young Bucks
25. Young Bucks
26. Takeshi Morishima
27. Colt Cabana
28. Tyler Black
29. Kyle O’Reilly
30. Eddie Edwards
31. Adam Cole
32. BJ Whitmer
33. Bobby Fish
34. James Gibson
35. Michael Elgin
36. Doug Williams
37. Jack Evans
38. Steve Corino
39. Rocky Romero
40. Naomichi Marufuji
41. Delirious
42. Matt Sydal
43. John Walters
44. Necro Butcher
45. Jushin Liger
46. Kenny Omega
47. Kushida
48. Go Shiozaki
49. Brian Kendrick
50. ACH

User avatar
Zubazkid
Posts: 32
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 3:10 am

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by Zubazkid » Tue Feb 28, 2017 12:34 pm

1. Samoa Joe
2. Bryan Danielson
3. Nigel McGuinness
4. Kevin Steen
5. Roderick Strong
6. Jay Briscoe
7. Homicide
8. Austin Aries
9. El Generico
10. A.J. Styles
11. KENTA
12. C.M. Punk
13. Low-Ki
14. Mark Briscoe
15. Christopher Daniels
16. Jay Lethal
17. Adam Cole
18. Takeshi Morishima
19. Tyler Black
20. Kyle O'Reilly
21. Eddie Edwards
22. Daley Richards
23. Naomichi Marufuji
24. Colt Cabana
25. Matt Jackson
26. Nick Jackson
27. Chris Hero
28. Claudio Castagnoli
29. Paul London
30. Jimmy Rave
31. Matt Sydal
32. Michael Elgin
33. James Gibson
34. Alex Shelley
35. Rocky Romero
36. Jack Evans
37. Bobby Fish
38. Steve Corino
39. ACH
40. Doug Williams
41. KUSHIDA
42. Go Shiozaki
43. John Walters
44. Shinto Takagi
45. Jimmy Jacobs
46. B.J. Whitmer
47. Jerry Lynn
48. Xavier
49. CIMA
50. Dragon Kid

User avatar
Rich Kraetsch
Site Admin
Posts: 2173
Joined: Mon Jun 29, 2015 7:12 pm
Location: Wheaton, IL
Contact:

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by Rich Kraetsch » Tue Feb 28, 2017 5:18 pm

1 Bryan Danielson
2 Samoa Joe
3 El Generico
4 Kevin Steen
5 AJ Styles
6 CM Punk
7 Jay Briscoe
8 Roderick Strong
9 Colt Cabana
10 Austin Aries
11 Davey Richards
12 Eddie Edwards
13 KENTA
14 Mark Briscoe
15 Christopher Daniels
16 Kyle O'Reilly
17 Nigel McGuinness
18 Matt Jackson
19 Nick Jackson
20 Jay Lethal
21 Claudio Castagnoli
22 Michael Elgin
23 Chris Hero
24 Low Ki
25 Raven
26 Homicide
27 Jimmy Rave
28 Tyler Black
29 Alex Shelley
30 Steve Corino
31 Takeshi Morishima
32 James Gibson
33 Amazing Red
34 Erick Stevens
35 Kenny King
36 Jack Evans
37 Chris Sabin
38 Jerry Lynn
39 Lance Storm
40 Necro Butcher
41 Dalton Castle
42 Paul London
43 Kenta Kobashi
44 CIMA
45 Naomichi Marufuji
46 Dragon Kid
47 Naruki Doi
48 Masato Yoshino
49 Shingo Takagi
50 Jimmy Jacobs

User avatar
mlev76
Posts: 2571
Joined: Tue Jun 30, 2015 11:32 pm
Location: New York, New York
Contact:

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by mlev76 » Tue Feb 28, 2017 6:01 pm

1. Samoa Joe
2. Bryan Danielson
3. Nigel McGuinness
4. Austin Aries
5. Jay Briscoe
6. CM Punk
7. Low Ki
8. Mark Briscoe
9. Roderick Strong
10. Homicide
11. Kevin Steen
12. Takeshi Morishima
13. Christopher Daniels
14. Tyler Black
15. El Generico
16. Aj Styles
17. Kenta
18. Colt Cabana
19. Jay Lethal
20. Davey Richards
21. Chris Hero
22. Claudio Castagnoli
23. Necro Butcher
24. Jimmy Rave
25. Young Bucks
26. Michael Elgin
27. Eddie Edwards
28. Adam Cole
29. Kyle O'Reilly
30. James Gibson
31. Jerry Lynn
32. Jack Evans
33. Alex Shelley
34. Matt Sydal
35. Raven
36. Paul London
37. Adam Pearce
38. Bobby Fish
39. Rocky Romero
40. Delirious
41. Xavier
42. Jimmy Jacobs
43. Bj Whitmer
44. Steve Corino
45. Doug Williams
46. Spanky
47. Go Shiozaki
48. ACH
49. Kenny King
50. Cedric Alexander

User avatar
dylanjstx
Posts: 126
Joined: Thu Dec 17, 2015 9:50 pm
Contact:

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by dylanjstx » Tue Feb 28, 2017 6:18 pm

1. Bryan Danielson
2. Samoa Joe
3. Jay Briscoe
4. Kevin Steen
5. AJ Styles
6. El Generico
7. Austin Aries
8. Low Ki
9. Christopher Daniels
10. Nigel McGuinness
11. CM Punk
12. KENTA
13. Mark Briscoe
14. Roderick Strong
15. Homicide
16. Amazing Red
17. Takeshi Morishima
18. Colt Cabana
19. Claudio Castagnoli
20. Chris Hero
21. Alex Shelley
22. Davey Richards
23. Tyler Black
24. Naomichi Marufuji
25. Jimmy Rave
26. Eddie Edwards
27. Kyle O’Reilly
28. Jimmy Jacobs
29. James Gibson
30. Matt Jackson
31. Nick Jackson
32. Paul London
33. Jay Lethal
34. Matt Sydal
35. Jack Evans
36. Dragon Kid
37. Naruki Doi
38. Masato Yoshino
39. Shingo Takagi
40. Steve Corino
41. Delirious
42. Go Shiozaki
43. Jerry Lynn
44. Michael Elgin
45. CIMA
46. Rocky Romero
47. Bobby Fish
48. Joel Maximo
49. Jose Maximo
50. Genki Horiguchi

User avatar
Rainmaker_F7
Posts: 370
Joined: Tue Jul 19, 2016 8:47 am
Location: Warsaw, Poland

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by Rainmaker_F7 » Tue Feb 28, 2017 6:54 pm

1. Bryan Danielson
2. Nigel McGuinness
3. Samoa Joe
4. CM Punk
5. Kevin Steen
6. Austin Aries
7. Jay Briscoe
8. El Generico
9. AJ Styles
10. Roderick Strong
11. Christopher Daniels
12. Mark Briscoe
13. Davey Richards
14. Low-Ki
15. Takeshi Morishima
16. KENTA
17. Eddie Edwards
18. Tyler Black
19. Homicide
20. Matt Jackson
21. Nick Jackson
22. Colt Cabana
23. Chris Hero
24. Kyle O'Reilly
25. Jimmy Rave
26. Jerry Lynn
27. Claudio Castagnoli
28. Jay Lethal
29. Jimmy Jacobs
30. Michael Elgin
31. Raven
32. James Gibson
33. Matt Sydal
34. Jack Evans
35. Amazing Red
36. Alex Shelley
37. Naomichi Marufuji
38. Paul London
39. Necro Butcher
40. Bobby Fish
41. Adam Cole
42. Rocky Romero
43. Kenny King
44. Kenny Omega
45. Steve Corino
46. ACH
47. Shingo Takagi
48. KUSHIDA
49. Kenta Kobashi (yes, for that one match alone, he deserves a place here)
50. Dragon Kid
Last edited by Rainmaker_F7 on Tue Feb 28, 2017 7:19 pm, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
BradPTBN
Posts: 338
Joined: Wed May 04, 2016 4:41 pm

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by BradPTBN » Tue Feb 28, 2017 6:59 pm

20. Matt & Nick Jackson - The Young Bucks (let me know if I can do it this way)

-- They gotta have their own rankings so it'll bump your #50. As a group they take up 2 spots.

User avatar
InYourCase
VOW Staff Member
Posts: 378
Joined: Tue Jun 30, 2015 9:50 pm
Location: Lanza's Dojo
Contact:

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by InYourCase » Tue Feb 28, 2017 11:23 pm

Bryan Danielson
Austin Aries
Samoa Joe
KENTA
Kevin Steen
Homicide
Low Ki
Christopher Daniels
CM Punk
Roderick Strong

Nigel McGuinness
El Generico
Jay Briscoe
Takeshi Morishima
AJ Styles
Alex Shelley
Naomichi Marufuji
James Gibson
Jimmy Jacobs

Matt Sydal
Colt Cabana
Douglas Williams
Mark Briscoe
Paul London
Kyle O’Reilly
Go Shiozaki
Jay Lethal
Young Bucks
Young Bucks

Chris Hero
Michael Elgin
Shingo Takagi
Amazing Red
Claudio Castagnoli
CIMA
Bobby Fish
Eddie Edwards
Jack Evans
Jimmy Rave

Adam Cole
Rocky Romero
Tyler Black
Davey Richards
Necro Butcher
Jushin Thunder Liger
Chris Sabin
Tommaso Ciampa
KUSHIDA
Masato Yoshino
Kenta Kobashi

User avatar
Joe Lanza
Site Admin
Posts: 2732
Joined: Tue Jun 30, 2015 11:00 pm

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by Joe Lanza » Wed Mar 01, 2017 12:09 am

Wow my list is WACKY~!

I based it on workrate, historical significance, influence, business, loosely in that order. Also went with my gut/my personal favorites a lot of the time, which isn't quantifiable, but tough shit, it's my list.

1. Bryan Danielson
2. Austin Aries
3. Jay Briscoe
4. Samoa Joe
5. Christopher Daniels
6. Kevin Steen
7. El Generico
8. Nigel McGuinness
9. KENTA
10. Mark Briscoe

11. Davey Richards
12. Roderick Strong
13. AJ Styles
14. Low Ki
15. Claudio Castagnoli
16. Chris Hero
17. Matt Jackson
18. Nick Jackson
19. Eddie Edwards
20. Kyle O'Reilly

21. Bobby Fish
22. Takeshi Morishima
23. Tyler Black
24. Michael Elgin
25. CM Punk
26. Homicide
27. Matt Sydal
28. Jack Evans
29. Alex Shelley
30. Kenta Kobashi

31. Jay Lethal
32. Naomichi Marufuji
33. Colt Cabana
34. Adam Cole
35. ACH
36. Katsuhiko Nakajima
37. Jimmy Rave
38. Rocky Romero
39. Go Shiozaki
40. CIMA

41. Naruki Doi
42. Dragon Kid
43. Ryo Saito
44. Genki Horiguchi
45. Masato Yoshino
46. Erick Stevens
47. Necro Butcher
48. Shingo Takagi
49. Jimmy Jacobs
50. Eddy Guerrero

I'm guessing James Gibson is my most notable snub.

User avatar
avengers23
Posts: 95
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2016 9:02 pm

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by avengers23 » Wed Mar 01, 2017 12:33 am

I started at the top and worked my way down based on feel. Where I had uncertainty, I went to look up how many matches they had in ROH according to Cagematch.
1. Bryan Danielson
2. Samoa Joe
3. Austin Aries
4. Jay Briscoe
5. Kevin Steen
6. Nigel McGuinness
7. Homicide
8. El Generico
9. KENTA
10. Low-Ki
11. CM Punk
12. Jimmy Rave
13. Roderick Strong
14. Claudio Castagnoli
15. Davey Richards
16. Chris Hero
17. AJ Styles
18. Paul London
19. Amazing Red
20. Takeshi Morishima
21. Jimmy Jacobs
22. Naruki Doi
23. Jack Evans
24. Christopher Daniels
25. Tyler Black
26. Young Bucks
27. Mark Briscoe
28. Rocky Romero
29. Eddie Edwards
30. Kyle O'Reilly
31. Jay Lethal
32. Necro Butcher
33. Alex Shelley
34. James Gibson
35. Matt Sydal
36. Steve Corino
37. Trent Acid
38. Kenta Kobashi
39. Jushin "Thunder" Liger
40. Raven
41. Colt Cabana
42. Shingo Takagi
43. Naomichi Marufuji
44. Ricky Reyes
45. BJ Whitmer
46. Adam Cole
47. Delirious
48. Bobby Dempsey
49. Xavier
50. Eddie Guerrero

Edit: Well, I'm not abandoning Eddie so I can fit Matt and Nick Jackson. Let's take out Adam Cole and replace him with Nick Jackson.

User avatar
avengers23
Posts: 95
Joined: Wed Mar 30, 2016 9:02 pm

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by avengers23 » Wed Mar 01, 2017 12:46 am

And the top 10 non-wrestler list:
1. Gabe Sapolsky
2. Dave Prazak
3. Lenny Leonard
4. Kevin Kelly
5. Prince Nana
6. Julius Smokes
7. Lacey
8. Cary Silkin
9. Shane Hagadorn
10. Larry Sweeney

User avatar
BackLash
Posts: 371
Joined: Sat Jul 18, 2015 3:39 am

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by BackLash » Wed Mar 01, 2017 1:11 am

These are some of the hardest decisions I've ever made as a wrestling fan, but fun nonetheless.

1. Bryan Danielson
2. Nigel McGuinness
3. Samoa Joe
4. Jay Lethal
5. CM Punk
6. Kevin Steen
7. Adam Cole
8. Jay Briscoe
9. Austin Aries
10. Tyler Black

11. Roderick Strong
12. Kyle O'Reilly
13. Davey Richards
14. A.J. Styles
15. Eddie Edwards
16. Takeshi Morishima
17. Michael Elgin
18. Homicide
19. Christopher Daniels
20. Jerry Lynn

21. Low Ki
22. Naomichi Marufuji
23. KENTA
24. Mark Briscoe
25. Chris Hero
26. Claudio Castagnoli
27. Matt Jackson
28. Nick Jackson
29. James Gibson
30. Colt Cabana

31. El Generico
32. Bobby Fish
33. Tommaso Ciampa
34. Hanson
35. Raymond Rowe
36. Steve Corino
37. Matt Sydal
38. ACH
39. Alex Shelley
40. Matt Taven

41. Rocky Romero
42. Cedric Alexander
43. Xavier
44. Jimmy Rave
45. Delirious
46. B.J. Whitmer
47. Jimmy Jacobs
48. Rhett Titus
49. Kenny King
50. Dalton Castle

User avatar
mrjoshdude
Posts: 213
Joined: Mon Aug 17, 2015 4:04 pm

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by mrjoshdude » Wed Mar 01, 2017 3:56 am

1. Bryan Danielson
2. Christopher Daniels
3. Samoa Joe
4. Nigel McGuinness
5. Kevin Steen
6. Austin Aries
7. CM Punk
8. Jay Briscoe
9. Roderick Strong
10. Homicide
11. Davey Richards
12. Low Ki
13. El Generico
14. AJ Styles
15. Adam Cole
16. Mark Briscoe
17. Jay Lethal
18. Takeshi Morishima
19. Tyler Black
20. KENTA
21. Kyle O'Reilly
22. Paul London
23. Alex Shelley
24. Claudio Castagnoli
25. Eddie Edwards
26. Michael Elgin
27. Jimmy Jacobs
28. BJ Whitmer
29. Chris Hero
30. Colt Cabana
31. The Young Bucks
32. Jushin Liger
33. Steve Corino
34. Brent Albright
35. Michael Shane
36. ACH
37. Jimmy Rave
38. Delirious
39. Matt Sydal
40. Bobby Fish
41. James Gibson
42. Jerry Lynn
43. Xavier
44. Cedric Alexander
45. Doug Williams
46. Kenny King
47. Lance Storm
48. Necro Butcher
49. Jack Evans
50. Tommaso Ciampa

User avatar
HeadCheese
Posts: 393
Joined: Fri Jul 03, 2015 9:21 pm
Location: Zonie Winner, Jesus Lover, Cheese`s Lover, and Pasta Eater. Maker of Bad Jokes. Great plugger.
Contact:

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by HeadCheese » Wed Mar 01, 2017 6:35 am

#10 Gedo
#9 Julius Smokes
#8 Kevin Kelly
#7 Lacey
#6 Shane Hagadorn
#5 Larry Sweeney
#4 Truth Martini
#3 Steve Corino
#2 Gabe Sapolsky
#1 Cary Silkin

User avatar
BITW3589
Posts: 28
Joined: Tue Mar 15, 2016 4:55 pm
Location: South Carolina
Contact:

Re: Ballot Sharing Thread

Post by BITW3589 » Wed Mar 01, 2017 8:36 am

50. Dragon Kid
49. Mike Quackenbush
48. Delirious
47. The Amazing Red
46. Jack Evans
45. Steve Corino
44. John Walters
43. Adam Pearce
42. Kenny Omega
41. Necro Butcher
40. Naruki Doi
39. Matt Sydal
38. CIMA
37. Masato Yoshino
36. Shingo Takagi
35. Doug Williams
34. BJ Whitmer
33. Naomichi Marufuji
32. James Gibson
31. Eddie Edwards
30. Davey Richards
29. Takeshi Morishima
28. Alex Shelley
27. Kyle O'Reilly
26. Jimmy Rave
25. Mark Briscoe
24. Claudio Castagnoli
23. Jay Lethal
22. Colt Cabana
21. Adam Cole
20. Spanky
19. Christopher Daniels
18. Roderick Strong
17. El Generico
16. Paul London
15. Jay Briscoe
14. Jimmy Jacobs
13. Tyler Black
12. KENTA
11. CM Punk
10. Young Bucks
9. Austin Aries
8. Kevin Steen
7. Chris Hero
6. Nigel McGuinness
5. Homicide
4. Low Ki
3. AJ Styles
2. Samoa Joe
1. Bryan Danielson

I guess Dragon Kid gets knocked off the list since I forgot the Young Bucks take up two spots.

Post Reply