Posted in

AEW Double or Nothing 2025 (May 25) Preview & Predictions

AEW Double or Nothing 2025
AEW Double or Nothing 2025

AEW DOUBLE OR NOTHING 2025
MAY 25, 2025
DESERT DIAMOND ARENA
GLENDALE, ARIZONA

Watch: Amazon / YouTube / Triller (Non-US) / PPV.com

Get Tickets: Ticketmaster / VividSeats / SeatGeek

Audio Review: Instant Reaction LIVE

MEET YOUR PREVIEWER

Suit Williams: You can read Suit’s long-form previews and reviews of wrestling from around the world here at Voices of Wrestling. Check out his blog Williams Watches Wrestling, where he’ll engage in watch projects like As Good As It Gets, his new project watching the best of 1997! Follow Suit on all social media platforms @SuitWilliams.

ANARCHY IN THE ARENA MATCH
THE DEATH RIDERS (JON MOXLEY, CLAUDIO CASTAGNOLI, WHEELER YUTA, MARINA SHAFIR) & THE YOUNG BUCKS VS. THE OPPS (SAMOA JOE, POWERHOUSE HOBBS, KATSUYORI SHIBATA), SWERVE STRICKLAND, KENNY OMEGA, & WILLOW NIGHTINGALE

The last thing I’m going to do is try to convince anyone that this Death Riders angle has been any kind of home run on top. I tolerate it more than I enjoy it. But I will say that since Grand Slam Australia, AEW has figured something out to where they haven’t been a negative to the TV product anymore. The angles have gotten hotter, the crowds are more receptive, and the Death Riders don’t feel like they’re dragging the company down from the top like they did at the start of 2025. What was the solution? Just have them show a ton of ass. Ever since Adam Copeland started taking out the Death Riders one-by-one, the babyface army has started to chip away at the Death Riders stranglehold of the company. They’re losing on TV more, The Opps won the Trios Titles on the phenomenal Spring BreakThru Dynamite, and the Death Riders feel vulnerable in a way that clearly has crowds excited. Now, the babyface army is set just in time for Anarchy In The Arena.

I’m not a big fan of stipulations like Anarchy in the Arena and Blood & Guts becoming yearly traditions, the same way I didn’t like the yearly stipulation matches in WWE. They continue to be AEW’s more dependable drawing matches every year, so it’s hard to argue that they should stop doing it for any reason other than artistic merit. It’s very cool seeing these names all come together in this big-time PPV main event, as three former AEW World Champions in Strickland, Omega, & Joe team up with Powerhouse Hobbs and Willow Nightingale to take on the big unit of heels in The Death Riders & The Young Bucks.

Personally, I would love it if the little shithead Wheeler Yuta got the pin on Willow just so he could brag about it like a little shithead would, but that’s obviously not happening. New Japan’s Gabe Kidd helped Moxley retain the World Title against Samoa Joe, and while he isn’t in the match officially, he’s been in the big group brawls to end Dynamite the last few weeks on the Death Riders side. I’ll pull a Babe Ruth and call my shot here, as I think we’ll see Eddie Kingston make his return to run off the man who broke his leg and put him on the shelf for the last year. Hook & PAC are also players to get involved, although their legitimate injuries could have them on the shelf past this show.

My prediction is that Kenny Omega will have Moxley dead to rights before Kazuchika Okada lays him out with a Rainmaker to set up the long-awaited renewal of their rivalry for All In Texas. They teased it when Omega returned at Worlds End in December – with the All In banner hanging behind them – and they teased it with their interactions in an eight-man tag on Dynamite a few weeks ago. What better place to run Okada/Omega for the first time in America than the biggest building they’ve ever run in this country? The bad guys survive, and one of the biggest matches AEW can run is all but made official. Prediction: The Death Riders & The Young Bucks

AEW CONTINENTAL TITLE MATCH
KAZUCHIKA OKADA VS. “SPEEDBALL” MIKE BAILEY

With his Elite teammates in Anarchy in the Arena, Kazuchika Okada defends his Continental Title against Speedball Mike Bailey. I thought Bailey was a decent pickup when AEW signed him, but the way AEW rolled Bailey and Kevin Knight out as energetic additions to the midcard has been fantastic. This match came about after Okada beat Knight in an eliminator match, when Bailey saved Knight from a post-match beat down. The result isn’t in doubt, but as is the case with all Okada matches in AEW, this will be as good as he feels like being on the night.

He went as hard as anyone could reasonably ask of him for over a decade in New Japan, so him taking it reasonably easy on American TV is understandable, if not ideal. But it’s the PPV matches where Okada has been a letdown to a degree, as he hasn’t been up to the degree you would want from Kazuchika Okada in big singles matches. It’s not a scenario where he’s over-the-hill by any means, it’s purely down to how hard he wants to go (with a little sprinkle of iffy booking in there). Speedball will be up to go all out, so all we can hope is that Okada feels like ramping it up here. Prediction: Kazuchika Okada

DANIEL GARCIA & NIGEL MCGUINNESS VS. FTR (CASH WHEELER & DAX HARWOOD) (W/STOKELY)

FTR turned on Adam Copeland at Dynasty, leaving him lying after losing a Trios Title match to the Death Riders. On the following episode of Collision on April 12th, they went from a stale babyface act to one of my favorite acts in the promotion in the span of an hour. They had a great angle threatening Tony Schiavone, forcing Nigel McGuinness out of his seat to make the save. Then, they bloodied up 2.0 in a match before turning on their other trios partner Daniel Garcia and leaving him in a heap as well. It was a phenomenal hour of TV that tied together all of the threads FTR had going on in the company, and it led to more awesome TV. They beat the Paragon twice to put that TV feud in the rearview, then Harwood and Garcia had a fantastic TV match that ended with McGuinness interfering after Harwood shoved him at the commentary desk. I have loved FTR’s work going into this show, and I think this match has a real chance to stand out on this card. FTR will win of course over the valiant but overmatched babyfaces, but they’ll stand tall as Adam Copeland will likely return to set up FTR’s direction for All In: Texas. Prediction: FTR

STRETCHER MATCH
MARK BRISCOE VS. RICOCHET

Good for Mark Briscoe getting on PPV for a SECOND month in a row! He’s gonna lose to Ricochet in this stretcher match, as Ricochet has become one of the more compelling characters in AEW as this fake-tough, fragile ego heel. This would be a great TNT Title feud, but that title is on Adam Cole so he can…watch Roderick Strong and Kyle O’Reilly wrestle on Collision. Cool. Anyway, this should be some easy heat for Ricochet as he gets his win back from a Dynamite loss back in New Orleans. It’s a stretcher match, so maybe we will get some Briscoe blood flowing too. Prediction: Ricochet



AEW WORLD TAG TEAM TITLE MATCH
THE HURT SYNDICATE (BOBBY LASHLEY & SHELTON BENJAMIN) (C) VS. THE SONS OF TEXAS (DUSTIN RHODES & SAMMY GUEVARA)

The Hurt Syndicate is a very over act, and the deal with MJF has been fun, but they have yet to have a standout match as champions. I doubt this will be that match as well, as the Syndicate is probably going to be the more over act between these two teams. For as sympathetic as Rhodes could be getting beaten and bloodied up by Lashley and Benjamin, I don’t think the AEW crowds want to get behind Sammy Guevara no matter how hard they try and how many breaks he takes from television. He’s just not a likable guy. There’s the intrigue with MJF, and while I think there will be a turn that ends with MJF siding with FTR and Stokely at some point, I don’t think it comes here. The result isn’t in question, I just hope we get something solid to sink our teeth into. Prediction: The Hurt Syndicate

AEW WOMEN’S WORLD TITLE MATCH
TONI STORM (W/LUTHER) (C) VS. MINA SHIRAKAWA

Timeless Toni had been keeping herself busy with Eliminator matches on TV as the Hart Foundation Tournament took place and got caught by the now-signed Mina Shirakawa with a small package reversal to give us this PPV defense. Mina is a fun TV act, and I’ve seen her have good matches in big spots, so I’m glad she got this spot as a filler defense ahead of All In. AEW has been teasing the debut of fellow STARDOM signee Thekla, with a mysterious red spider showing up on the screen, so that could be a possible TV feud coming out of this for Shirakawa.

To talk about Toni for a moment, she’s been on the run of her career since the Hollywood Ending, both in terms of in-ring and her overness with the crowd. My issue with her and Mariah’s feud is that neither of them really stepped it up in-ring when they weren’t against each other, but that’s a thing of the past. I thought her match with Megan Bayne at Dynasty was awesome, and she feels like one of the biggest stars in the promotion regardless of gender. With a quality match here that I think both women are capable of having, she’s going to go into All In red-hot. Prediction: Toni Storm

2025 OWEN HART FOUNDATION WOMEN’S TOURNAMENT FINAL MATCH
MERCEDES MONE VS. JAMIE HAYTER

I’ve had about a dozen different ideas for the women’s division since the Timeless Toni/Mariah May saga ended. The top end of this division is loaded with high-end talent like the two women here, the women in the World Title match, Kris Statlander, Willow Nightingale, Megan Bayne, and Athena (if she still exists). The result of this match comes down to whether Tony Khan wants to run the biggest women’s match they have for All In, or if he wants to hold off for another show that will need a marquee match. Toni Storm vs. Mercedes Moné is one of the biggest matches in the company regardless of gender, and it would make sense to run it at the big stadium show.

However, there are just too many big names being left out of the mix for them to tie both titles up in the Storm/Moné match. Maybe they would run a Women’s Casino Gauntlet or something to get all those names on the show. But with Willow and Statlander’s rivalry reheating, and both women having issues with Moné in the past, I can easily see Moné defending the TBS Title against either or both women at All In.

Meanwhile, Jamie Hayter has a built-in story against Toni Storm, with Storm having put Hayter on the shelf with the Outcasts all the way back at Double or Nothing 2023 and costing her the title and a match at both Wembley shows. Hayter and Storm had one of the best women’s matches in company history back at Full Gear 2022, and with Storm rounding into top form after the incredible Hollywood Ending back at Revolution, I can see them topping it on the biggest stage of the year. I made this argument back at WrestleMania 35, and I’ll make it here: Why only have one big women’s match when you can have two? Prediction: Jamie Hayter

2025 OWEN HART FOUNDATION MEN’S TOURNAMENT FINAL MATCH
HANGMAN PAGE VS. WILL OSPREAY

Suit: I want to preface my preview of this match by saying that I like Hangman Page as a wrestler. I think he is undeniably one of the best wrestlers on this roster, and I wouldn’t be upset or surprised if he won this match. With that said, I am sick and tired of this guy being sad all the goddamn time. His promo in Detroit really stuck in my craw, as his “I don’t even know why you guys like me” fishing for cheers annoyed the hell out of me. Hangman has been in this company since day one, seven entire years, and he’s been happy for about eight cumulative months. He can’t even be happy that he won his blood feud with Swerve Strickland because of his emotions. It’s always some form of anguish or sadness or inner turmoil with this guy. His energy is so heavy, like he’s burdened to be around. If you worked with someone who had Hangman’s energy for SEVEN years, you wouldn’t want to be caught in the lunch room with them while they sighed about their life for an hour.

Compare that to Will Ospreay’s energy. He’s had a blood feud in his time with the company. He’s lost big matches. He’s lost championships. But unlike the Big Sad Boy Adam Page, he feels so happy and energized to be in AEW. He’s got a spirit and an energy that Hangman doesn’t have, and while it helps Hangman to be a deeper character, I’d rather the world-class wrestler at the top of the promotion not feel like a fuckin’ drag. 

In writing this, I realized that I’m actually on the same side as the Hangman fans as we both want Hangman to stop being sad. They want him to stop being sad to complete his hero’s journey or whatever the fuck, while I want this wrestler that I like to stop being such a self-pitying loser. The only way to stop being a loser is to win, so yeehaw, I guess. Plus, Ospreay has basically given it away in his promos, talking about this being Hangman’s redemption and promising to be his backup against the Death Riders if Hangman beat him. So, for all of our sakes Hangman, get the job done here. Prediction: Hangman Page



Suit Williams has been a VOW contributor since 2017, writing opinion pieces and reviews of pro wrestling from around the world. Find more of his work at SuitWilliams.com.